Skip to Main Content

Header Bars

Comics
new releases
publishers
- Boom Studios
- Dark Horse
- DC Comics
- Dynamite
- IDW
- Image Comics
- Independents
- Marvel Comics
- Valiant Comics
- Vertigo
categories
Site-to-store
- Order Back Issues For In-store Pickup
- FREE BAG & BOARD
  
  WITH EVERY COMIC
- FREESHIPPING
  
  ON QUALIFYING ORDERS
characters
Variants/Incentives
New releases
Site-to-store
- Order Back Issues For In-store Pickup
- FREE BAG & BOARD
  
  WITH EVERY COMIC
- FREESHIPPING
  
  ON QUALIFYING ORDERS
publishers
Back Issues
publishers
- Archie
- Charlton
- Dark Horse
- DC Comics
- Dell
- Dynamite
- Gold Key
- IDW Publishing
- Image Comics
- Independents
- Marvel Comics
Site-to-store
- Order Back Issues For In-store Pickup
- FREE BAG & BOARD
  
  WITH EVERY COMIC
- FREESHIPPING
  
  ON QUALIFYING ORDERS
categories
recently added
- Past Week
- Past Month
Graphic Novels
new releases
publishers
- Dark Horse
- DC
- Dynamite
- IDW Publishing
- Image
- Marvel
- Independents
categories
characters
Books
new releases
publishers
categories
- Art Books
- Audio Books
- Best Sellers
- Fiction
- How-To
- Non-Fiction
- Stationery
- Signed Books
- Young Adult
- Young Readers
Magazines
new releases
publishers
categories
Manga
new releases
publishers
categories
- Manhwa
- Shojo
- Shonen
- Yaoi
Apparel
new releases
characters
- Batman
- Captain America
- Flash
- GI Joe
- Green Lantern
- Hulk
- Iron Man
- Spider-Man
- Star Trek
- Star Wars
- Superman
- Transformers
- X-Men
- Wonder Woman
- View More...
manufacturers
categories
Statues
new releases
characters
- Batman
- Captain America
- Flash
- GI Joe
- Green Lantern
- Hulk
- Iron Man
- Spider-Man
- Star Trek
- Star Wars
- Superman
- Transformers
- X-Men
- Wonder Woman
- View More...
manufacturers
categories
Action Figures
new releases
japanese imports
characters
- Batman
- Captain America
- Flash
- GI Joe
- Green Lantern
- Hulk
- Iron Man
- Spider-Man
- Star Trek
- Star Wars
- Superman
- Transformers
- X-Men
- Wonder Woman
- View More...
manufacturers
categories
Collectibles
new releases
manufacturers
- Ata Boy
- Dark Horse
- Funko
- Neca
- Popfun
characters
- Batman
- Captain America
- Flash
- GI Joe
- Green Lantern
- Hulk
- Iron Man
- Spider-Man
- Star Trek
- Star Wars
- Superman
- Transformers
- X-Men
- Wonder Woman
- View More...
categories
Gaming and Cards
new releases
manufacturers
categories
Supplies
manufacturers
categories
Clearance
Pull List
Pre-Orders
Deals of The Day
Gift Cards

search When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select.

Profile
Go to Account Settings

New customer? Create an Account
MY ACCOUNT

Account Settings

My Orders

My Wish List

Manage Gift Cards

My Address Book

My Credit Cards

My Newsletters Settings

MY PRE-ORDERS

My Pre-Order Items

My Pre-Order Orders

Pre-Orders Catalogs

Pre-Orders FAQ

MY PULL LIST

My Pull List

Pull List FAQ
1 items in pull list

1 items in pull list
Your Pull List

1 Items in Pull List

Add 10 more regular titles to complete your Pull List

0

10
- A Curtain Call For You (non-regular)
  
  Remove
  
  1
What's a Pull List?
View Cart

0 Items In Cart

Spend $89.00 to receive FREE Shipping on Comics!

$0.00

$89
Total $0.00

Home

Departments
Departments
My Account
My Account
Weekly Releases
Track My Order
Browsing History
Variants & Incentives
Clearance
Stores
We Buy Comics
Gift Cards

FREE SHIPPING
6/17 Weekly Releases
Weekly Releases
- 6/17
- 6/10
- 6/3
- 5/27
- 5/20
- 5/13
- 5/6
- 4/29
- 4/22
- 4/15
- 4/8
- 4/1
Newly Added Back Issues
FREE BAG & BOARD WITH EVERY COMIC

FREE SHIPPING ON QUALIFYING ORDERS
Track My Order
Browsing History
Save Up to 50% With Pre-Orders
Variants & Incentives
Clearance
Stores
We Buy Comics
Gift Cards

Midtown Comics - Search

Search Page

RESULTS for "Mystery Comics #"

Show out of stock Include Pre-orders

Show Out of stock and pre-orders Choosing a filter will refresh the page.
Show out of stock

Include Pre-orders
Per Page
Sort by

Choosing a filter will refresh the page.

Close Filters Filters

Show out of stock

Search Summary

Mystery Comics #
Comics/Back Issues
Independents

Category

Comics/Back Issues (14)

Release Week

May 20, 2026 (1)

Custom Release Week

Release Year

1 month ago (1)
6 month ago (1)
1 year ago (1)
2010s (9)
2000s (1)
1990s (1)
1950s (Of1)
1940s And earlier (2)

From:

To:

Series

View All

Boris Karloff Tales Of Mystery (1)
Boris Karloffs Gold Key Mysteries (2)
Classics Illustrated (1)
Freaks Gods Vol 2 (1)
Men Of Mystery (1)
Moonstone Mysterious Traveler Returns (1)
Mysterious Strangers (1)
Mysterious Traveler Comics (1)
Pooh Bear Adventures Piglets Very Bad Day (1)
True Horror Mysteries Babysitter Killer Other Stories (3)

Sub Category

Independents (14)

Discount

0%-10% (2)
10%-20% (12)

Manufacturer/Publisher

AC Comics (1)
Classics Illustrated (1)
Gold Key (1)
Gold Key Entertainment (2)
Invader Comics (1)
Keenspot Entertainment (1)
Moonstone (1)
Oni Press (1)
Source Point Press (1)
Trans-World Publications (1)

Zenescope Entertainment (3)

Artist

Bob Powell (1)
Dustin Irvin (1)
Giuseppe D'Elia (1)
Kraig Rasmussen (2)
Reed Crandall (1)
Scott Kowalchuk (1)
Tessa Rose (1)
Trevor Von Eeden (1)
Various (1)

Writer

Chris Dreier (1)
Chris Roberson (1)
Ed Cronin (1)
Joe Gentile (1)
Joshua Werner (1)
Matt Cole (1)
Michael Conrad (2)
Various (1)

Price

Clearance
Under $5 (1)
$05 - $09 (7)
$10 - $19 (1)
$20 & Above (5)

Issue No

0 - 1 series (8)
2 - 50 series (5)
101 - 500 series (1)

Pooh Bear Adventures Piglets Very Bad Day #1 (One Shot) Cover D Variant Surprise Mystery Bagged Cover & Trading Card With Polybag (Filled Randomly)

By: Keenspot Entertainment
Release Date: 05/20/2026*
Writer(s) :: Matt Cole
Artist(s) :: Tessa Rose

Original price:

$6.99

Current price:

$6.29

10% OFF

Choose Qty for Pooh Bear Adventures Piglets Very Bad Day #1 (One Shot) Cover D Variant Surprise Mystery Bagged Cover & Trading Card With Polybag (Filled Randomly)

Choose Qty for Pooh Bear Adventures Piglets Very Bad Day #1 (One Shot) Cover D Variant Surprise Mystery Bagged Cover & Trading Card With Polybag (Filled Randomly)

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Available For Pull List!

Freaks & Gods Vol 2 #2 Mystery Of The Crypto Tomb

By: Invader Comics
Release Date: 06/29/2022*
Writer(s) :: Chris Dreier
Artist(s) :: Giuseppe D'Elia
ISBN :: 9781636259789

Select a Grade

Original price:

$6.39

Current price:

$5.75

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Available For Pull List!

Winchester Mystery House #1 Cover A Regular Dustin Irvin Cover

By: Source Point Press
Release Date: 10/27/2021*
Writer(s) :: Joshua Werner
Artist(s) :: Dustin Irvin

Select a Grade

Original price:

$5.19

Current price:

$4.67

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Available For Pull List!

Men Of Mystery #101

By: AC Comics
Release Date: 09/07/2016*
Writer(s) :: Ed Cronin; Various
Artist(s) :: Reed Crandall; Various

Select a Grade

Original price:

$34.10

Current price:

$30.69

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Boris Karloff Tales Of Mystery #8

By: Gold Key
Release Date: 12/01/1965*

Select a Grade

Original price:

$70.00

Current price:

$63.00

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Mysterious Traveler Comics #1 Cover B CGC 4.5

By: Trans-World Publications
Release Date: 11/01/1948*
Artist(s) :: Bob Powell

Current price:

$850.00

Choose Qty for Mysterious Traveler Comics #1 Cover B CGC 4.5

Choose Qty for Mysterious Traveler Comics #1 Cover B CGC 4.5

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Classics Illustrated #34 Cover A 1st Ptg Classic Comics Mysterious Island

By: Classics Illustrated
Release Date: 02/01/1947*
Writer(s) :: Various
Artist(s) :: Various

Select a Grade

Original price:

$100.00

Current price:

$90.00

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

True Horror Mysteries Babysitter Killer & Other Stories #1 (One Shot) Cover L Michael Dooney Belle Regular Retailer Variant Cover

By: Zenescope Entertainment
Release Date: 04/03/2024*

Select a Grade

Original price:

$20.51

Current price:

$18.46

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

True Horror Mysteries Babysitter Killer & Other Stories #1 (One Shot) Cover N Michael Dooney Belle Risque Retailer Variant Cover

By: Zenescope Entertainment
Release Date: 04/03/2024*

Select a Grade

Current price:

$75.51

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Available For Pull List!

True Horror Mysteries Babysitter Killer & Other Stories #1 (One Shot) Cover A Regular Leonardo Colapietro Cover

By: Zenescope Entertainment
Release Date: 03/13/2024*

Select a Grade

Original price:

$8.69

Current price:

$7.82

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Available For Pull List!

Boris Karloffs Gold Key Mysteries #2 Cover A Regular Johnny Dombrowski Cover

By: Gold Key Entertainment
Release Date: 02/14/2024*
Writer(s) :: Michael Conrad
Artist(s) :: Kraig Rasmussen

Select a Grade

Original price:

$7.49

Current price:

$6.74

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Boris Karloffs Gold Key Mysteries #2 Cover B Incentive Kraig Rasmussen Gold Foil Variant Cover

By: Gold Key Entertainment
Release Date: 02/14/2024*
Writer(s) :: Michael Conrad
Artist(s) :: Kraig Rasmussen

Select a Grade

Original price:

$10.51

Current price:

$9.46

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Available For Pull List!

Mysterious Strangers #1 Cover A Regular Edition

By: Oni Press
Release Date: 07/17/2013*
Writer(s) :: Chris Roberson
Artist(s) :: Scott Kowalchuk

Select a Grade

Original price:

$5.89

Current price:

$5.30

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Moonstone Mysterious Traveler Returns

By: Moonstone
Release Date: 01/28/2004*
Writer(s) :: Joe Gentile
Artist(s) :: Trevor Von Eeden

Select a Grade

Original price:

$7.09

Current price:

$6.38

10% OFF

Order online for In-Store Pick up
At any of our four locations

Show Out of stock and pre-orders Choosing a filter will refresh the page.
Show out of stock

Include Pre-orders
Per Page
Sort by

1-14 of 14 in all categories

Close Sort By Sort By

New Releases

New Releases

title

Title

Lowest Price

Lowest Price

Highest Price

Highest Price

Get The Latest Scoop!

Subscribe to our newsletter for special savings and offers!

Email:

Weekly
Daily Deals
Back Issues

Contact Information
Wikipedia
Midtown Comics News

Download

Midtown Comics QR

Midtown Comics QR

Download Now!

Downtown
Grand Central
Times Square
Astoria Outlet

Facebook
Instagram
Twitter
Youtube

Order Status
Account Settings
Subscription Settings
Check Gift Card Balance
Subscriptions / Pull List FAQ
Pull List
Pre-Orders FAQ
Pre-Orders

In-Store Pick-up
Sitemap
FAQ
CGC FAQ
Privacy Policy
Unsubscribe Newsletter
Terms & Conditions
Shipping Information
Accessibility Information

Midtown Comics QR

Midtown Comics QR

Download Now!

facebook
twitter
youtube
instagram

© Copyright 2026 Midtown Comics. All rights reserved.

ADA Compliance Notice

We are committed to ensure digital accessibility for everyone. We're constantly improving the user experience by applying relevant accessibility standards to make our website compliant with the World Wide Web Consortium's "Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1" (WCAG 2.1), a set of guidelines adopted by a private group designed to maximize accessibility of web content.

Accessibility Information

Cookies & Privacy

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.
Read more about our privacy policy

Necessary cookies help with the basic functionality of our website, e.g remember if you gave consent to cookies.

Analytical cookies make it possible to gather statistics about the use and trafiic on our website, so we can make it better.